The FCC’s Course Correction to Accelerate Deployment in 2018
However, there is still room for improvement: 24 million Americans remain without baseline broadband access. These underserved Americans are primarily located within rural areas or on tribal lands.
During the two-year period of 2014 to 2016, new broadband deployments decreased by 55 percent, new mobile deployments dropped 83 percent, and the pace of Americans gaining access to both fixed terrestrial broadband and mobile broadband was nearly three times slower.
Led by Chairman Ajit Pai, the FCC’s position is that this dramatic slowdown in broadband deployment is largely the result of the 2015 Title II Order, which established net neutrality. The FCC’s report describes the steps taken to breathe new life into nationwide broadband deployment.
Title II: Net Neutrality vs. Broadband Deployment
However, the order also effectively stifled innovation by requiring ISPs to submit proposals to the FCC for new business models. To consider the impact of these regulations, companies like Facebook and T-Mobile were required to request permission from the FCC to launch new apps and services. The review process and long debates dragged on for months, establishing regulatory uncertainty within the industry.
To illustrate the impact that Title II had on broadband deployment, the FCC offered the following statistics:
Past Deployment Success: From 2012 to 2014, the two years preceding the Title II Order:
- Fixed terrestrial broadband Internet access was deployed to 29.9 million people who never had it before, including 1 million people in tribal lands.
- Mobile LTE broadband was newly deployed to 34.2 million people, including 21.5 million rural Americans.
- The number of Americans without access to both fixed terrestrial broadband and mobile broadband fell by more than half—from 72.1 million to 34.5 million.
Deployment Stall After Title II: From 2014-2016, following the adoption of Title II Order:
- New deployments dropped 55 percent, reaching only 13.5 million people, including only 330,000 people on tribal lands.
- New mobile deployments dropped 83 percent, reaching only 5.8 million more Americans, including only 2.3 million more rural Americans.
- The pace of Americans gaining access to both fixed terrestrial broadband and mobile broadband was nearly three times slower than the prior 2 years, with only 13.9 million Americans newly receiving access to both over the next two years.
Acting to Speed Up Broadband Deployment
Last December, the FCC voted to remove the restrictions barring ISPs from slowing down or speeding up web traffic based on business relationships, and on February 22, 2018, the FCC formally overturned the 2015 Title II Order. In its place, the FCC has published the “Restoring Internet Freedom Order,” which replaces the previously restrictive regulations with a “light-touch regulatory framework” that requires ISPs to publicly disclose their practices to enable customers to make informed choices. The new order will take effect on April 23.
Our next blog post in this series will look at additional steps the current FCC is taking to prioritize broadband deployment to all Americans.